Skip to main content
Spirit Led Institute crestSpirit Led Institute
Back to Spirit Led Institute

Spirit Led Institute · Article

The Hidden Power Struggle: When a Woman Just Wants to Do Her Job

Recognising the pattern, understanding its cost, and reclaiming your dignity

By Sharon Mackenzie | Spirit Led Institute

There is a pattern of behaviour I have witnessed throughout my life, particularly in workplaces, churches and faith-based organisations. It is one of the most destructive patterns I have encountered, and it has taken me 53 years to fully recognise it, understand its consequences and develop the language to explain it.

It is the covert power struggle between a person in authority and someone whose natural abilities, competence and independence are perceived as a challenge to that authority.

I have watched this pattern unfold in the lives of other women, and I have experienced it myself. I know how exhausting it is. I know how confusing it can become. And I know how much of a person's life can be consumed by trying to resolve something they never knowingly entered into.

What makes this pattern particularly dangerous is that it is rarely announced.

Nobody sits you down and tells you that you are now participating in a power struggle. You simply begin to encounter resistance, obstruction, inconsistency and a remarkable lack of cooperation.

And because you don't understand what is happening, you keep trying harder.

When competence becomes a perceived threat

There are women who possess natural leadership abilities. They are capable, intelligent, discerning, independent and confident in their judgement. They can recognise problems, develop solutions and take responsibility for getting things done.

They aren't necessarily interested in being in charge of anybody. They simply want to contribute their abilities and do their jobs well.

But when these women work under leaders who perceive independence and competence as threats to their authority, an unhealthy dynamic can develop.

A woman brings forward a proposal, and it is rejected. She identifies a problem, and nothing is done. She suggests a better process, but cannot obtain cooperation. Meetings are delayed or cancelled. Decisions are withheld. She finds herself continually waiting for approval to do work that she has already been employed to undertake.

Individually, any of these things might have a reasonable explanation. But when they become a persistent pattern, particularly when the woman is repeatedly prevented from exercising her legitimate responsibilities, something more serious may be occurring.

The issue may no longer be the quality of her work.

It may be a struggle over who gets to exercise influence and control.

And this is something women need to understand: you can be involved in a power struggle without having any desire to compete for power.

You may be seeking cooperation while the person above you is seeking control.

The double standard surrounding female authority

Research has documented a phenomenon known as gender backlash, in which women can face negative reactions for displaying authority, assertiveness or dominance that may be more readily accepted from men.

A meta-analysis published in 2016 found that dominant behaviour could negatively affect women's likeability and hiring evaluations relative to men's, particularly when that dominance was expressed explicitly. Other research has found that women in leadership roles can encounter greater backlash when making decisions.

This doesn't mean every disagreement between a male manager and a female employee is a gender-based power struggle. But it does help explain why capable women can sometimes experience resistance that has little to do with their professional competence.

In some environments, a man who demonstrates authority may be viewed as a strong leader, while a woman demonstrating similar qualities may be regarded as difficult, confrontational or challenging.

And if that interpretation becomes embedded within an organisation's leadership culture, a capable woman may spend years trying to correct a problem that does not originate in her performance.

The trap: believing you need to try harder

This is where the damage begins.

When a woman cannot understand why her manager continually obstructs her work, she naturally begins looking for ways to improve the situation.

Perhaps she needs to communicate more clearly. Perhaps she should prepare a better proposal. Perhaps she needs to understand his personality, demonstrate greater patience or prove that she isn't trying to undermine him.

She might even change roles, believing that a different position will finally allow her to exercise her abilities without the ongoing conflict.

And so she works harder.

She becomes more conscientious, more accommodating, more careful about what she says and how she says it.

But if the underlying issue is an entrenched struggle over power and control, improving her performance may do nothing to resolve it.

In some situations, greater competence may actually produce greater resistance.

The woman believes she is trying to solve a workplace problem. She doesn't realise that she is exhausting herself trying to manage someone else's relationship with authority.

I have watched women lose confidence in themselves through this process. I have seen the stress become overwhelming, with consequences for their physical health, emotional wellbeing and sense of identity.

And one of the cruelest aspects is that they often blame themselves.

They begin to wonder whether they really are difficult. Whether they have a personality problem. Whether they are too outspoken, too independent or simply incapable of working with other people.

But sometimes the problem is not that a woman lacks the ability to cooperate.

Sometimes she is working with someone who will not cooperate with her.

Responsibility without authority: another dimension of the struggle

There is another feature of this pattern that deserves attention.

Some leaders retain control over decisions while allowing the responsibility for identifying problems, anticipating consequences and absorbing workplace pressures to fall onto the people beneath them.

The employee becomes responsible for recognising what needs attention but has little meaningful influence over the decisions required to address it.

She may be expected to monitor problems, raise concerns, protect the organisation, support the leader and compensate for weaknesses in the system.

Yet when she attempts to exercise initiative, she encounters resistance.

She is expected to carry responsibility without being given corresponding authority.

This creates an exhausting contradiction.

She can see what is wrong but cannot correct it. She can recognise what needs to happen but cannot obtain a decision. She may become deeply concerned about the consequences of management choices while having no control over those choices herself.

Over time, a conscientious employee can begin to carry an extraordinary amount of invisible responsibility.

And the organisation may come to rely on that willingness without formally recognising the burden.

But being capable of identifying a problem does not automatically make a person responsible for resolving it.

Responsibility needs legitimate boundaries.

When the organisation protects the pattern

One of the most difficult things for women to accept is that an entrenched workplace power struggle may not be something they can resolve through better communication or another complaints process.

If a leader has repeatedly behaved in ways that obstruct employees, damage relationships and undermine their ability to work, and the organisation has allowed that behaviour to continue, the problem extends beyond the individual.

Organisations establish leadership structures. They appoint managers. They create reporting arrangements, determine who holds decision-making authority and establish processes for accountability.

If harmful behaviour repeatedly goes unaddressed, those structures need examination.

And yet the burden of obtaining change is frequently placed on the employee experiencing the harm.

She is told to document incidents, preserve emails, raise complaints, seek mediation, attend meetings and demonstrate that she has attempted to resolve the conflict.

There may be circumstances in which these processes are useful. But when a woman has already spent years trying to work within a deeply dysfunctional power arrangement, asking her to keep pursuing resolution can become another source of exhaustion.

She was employed to do a job.

She was not employed to reform the character of her manager or repair the organisation's failures of accountability.

Australian workplace safety guidance recognises that low job control, poor organisational justice, role conflict and destructive workplace relationships can create serious psychosocial risks. These are organisational issues, not simply matters of individual resilience.

When an organisation repeatedly allows harmful leadership behaviour to continue, the person experiencing that behaviour should not be expected to sacrifice years of her life trying to make the organisation hold its own leaders accountable.

My advice to women: recognise the pattern and walk away

I want to be very clear about my position.

If you recognise that you are trapped in an entrenched, destructive power struggle, particularly one that has continued for years despite your efforts to resolve it, I would encourage you to leave.

I would not encourage you to spend another two or three years trying to find the perfect way to communicate with someone who consistently refuses to cooperate.

I would not encourage you to exhaust yourself gathering more evidence in the hope that someone will finally acknowledge what is happening.

And I would not encourage you to believe that demonstrating greater competence, loyalty or patience will necessarily change a leader who is invested in maintaining control.

I recognise that leaving a job is not always immediately possible. Women have financial responsibilities, families, commitments and circumstances that may require careful planning. Leaving may need to be a deliberate process rather than an immediate action.

But that is very different from making it your mission to change a dysfunctional leader or institution.

You do not have to win a power struggle to preserve your dignity.

You can recognise what is happening and choose not to continue participating in it.

That decision does not mean you have failed.

It means you have recognised the cost of remaining.

The cost is greater than a job

I speak about this with such conviction because I know what it has cost me.

I have experienced this pattern in more than one organisational setting, involving someone I once respected deeply. I loved my work. I wanted to contribute. I wanted to cooperate and use the abilities I had been given.

But the working relationship became extraordinarily difficult.

Over time, I began to recognise that many of the obstacles I was encountering were not simply communication problems. They were part of a recurring struggle over authority and control.

I experienced the consequences of that struggle across two communities that had been important parts of my life.

Leaving those communities came at a considerable personal cost.

It has taken me approximately eighteen months to begin fully understanding and untangling those experiences.

I have also been dealing with Hashimoto's thyroiditis, an autoimmune condition. I cannot establish what role prolonged stress may have played in my own health, but I know that the experiences I have lived through have taken a toll on me.

And I know that continuing to revisit them is no longer something I want to ask of myself.

There is a point at which understanding what happened becomes important not merely because it explains the past, but because it allows you to stop living within it.

A word to Christian women

I particularly want to speak to women in churches and Christian organisations.

Your God-given abilities are not a threat that must be dismantled before you can be useful.

You were created in the image of God. Your intelligence, discernment, leadership abilities and internal authority are not defects that require correction simply because you are a woman.

I reject the idea that a woman must be diminished, silenced or broken in order to become suitable for service.

God did not give you abilities so that another human being could systematically destroy your confidence in using them.

Your dignity does not depend on the approval of a male leader.

And your calling does not require you to remain indefinitely in an environment where your abilities are continually obstructed and your wellbeing is being damaged.

Leaving such an environment is not necessarily abandoning your calling.

Sometimes leaving is what allows you to begin exercising it freely.

Why I created Spirit Led Institute

I have written twelve books, developed courses and established an entire Institute because I wanted people to have language for the harmful patterns they encounter.

Every book, course and resource has grown from experiences I have lived through, examined and worked to understand.

I wanted to make that understanding available to others.

I wanted women to recognise destructive patterns before spending years of their lives trapped within them. I wanted people to understand what was happening in their workplaces, churches, families and relationships so they could make informed choices about whether to participate.

I especially wanted younger people to have access to knowledge that took me decades to acquire.

Spirit Led Institute was built out of the ashes of experiences that caused me considerable harm.

But it was built with a purpose that extends far beyond those experiences.

I want people to recognise harm, understand how it operates, and recover the freedom to make their own decisions.

I want that work to remain available for generations to come.

Why I need to move beyond the experiences that created this work

There is something else I want to share with those who have followed my teaching.

Whenever I record a video discussing harmful patterns and direct people to Spirit Led Institute, hundreds of people visit the website. People read the resources, explore the courses and purchase my books.

That has been deeply encouraging because it means the work is reaching people.

But I have discovered something about myself.

Every time I sit down to record another video about these experiences, I have to revisit the things that happened to me.

I have to remember what it felt like. I have to return to the injustice, the confusion, the exhaustion and the pain.

And I am finding that increasingly difficult.

This particular video was especially hard to record. I attempted it several times because I struggled to find the words and remain composed while discussing the subject.

And I have realised that, although sharing these experiences may help other people, continually returning to them is no longer helping me.

I have spent years examining harmful patterns and turning that understanding into resources.

But I do not want to spend the rest of my life reliving those experiences simply to keep promoting the work that came from them.

There is a difference between using painful experiences to develop wisdom and repeatedly returning to those experiences at the expense of your own peace.

I want to continue contributing to healing ministry. I want Spirit Led Institute to remain available to the people who need it.

But I also want the freedom to discover what comes next in my own life.

For that reason, this may be one of the last times I appear personally in a video discussing these experiences. I will continue sharing resources and making the Institute's work available, but I want to allow myself to move forward.

The books are written. The courses are developed. The resources are available.

The work can stand.

And I can begin exploring other things.

Your dignity is found in recognising that you have a choice

If there is one thing I want people to take away from my work, it is this:

Learn to recognise the patterns operating around you.

Recognise when you are being drawn into a power struggle you never agreed to enter.

Recognise when your abilities are being obstructed rather than welcomed.

Recognise when responsibility is being placed on your shoulders without the authority to exercise it.

And recognise when an organisation is asking you to carry the consequences of leadership behaviour that it refuses to address.

You cannot always control the behaviour of the people around you. You cannot force someone to cooperate, communicate honestly or exercise their authority responsibly.

But understanding the pattern gives you something important.

It gives you the ability to make an informed choice.

You can decide what you will participate in, what you will carry, and when the cost of remaining has become too great.

You do not have to sacrifice your health, your calling, your abilities or years of your life trying to win a power struggle you never wanted.

Your dignity is not found in defeating the person who opposes you.

It is found in remembering that you have the authority to choose how you will live.

And sometimes, my darling, that means turning around and walking away.


Sharon Mackenzie

Founder, Spirit Led Institute

www.spiritledinstitute.com

Research and further reading

Watch

Eucalyptus overlooking an Australian valley at sunsetGolden Australian wattle flowers at sunset