
When Dignity Is Diminished, Belonging Begins to Break
Understanding the hidden wounds of disrespect, humiliation and spiritual leadership — and the journey towards restoration
By Sharon Mackenzie | Spirit Led Institute
Understanding Dignity and Belonging
The following definitions and connection were taken from a Google search that prompted my reflection on this subject.
Dignity: The inherent, unearned worth that every person possesses simply by being human, requiring respect, honor, and freedom from humiliation.
Belonging: The feeling of being welcome, valued, and safe to exist authentically within a community or institution without having to change who you are.
The Connection: Dignity is who you are (an acknowledged person), while belonging is where you fit (a recognized member of the group).
Source: Google search summary, 27 October 2026.
There is something I want to talk about that matters deeply to me: the connection between human dignity and belonging.
It is a connection I have come to understand through my own experiences, particularly within Christian communities and organisational leadership. It is also one of the foundational concerns behind the development of Spirit Led Institute.
What struck me about these definitions was their simplicity and their significance.
Dignity concerns who we are. Belonging concerns whether there is room for us to be who we are.
The relationship between these two things is profound.
When a person is repeatedly disrespected, dishonoured, humiliated or treated as though their voice and contribution do not matter, something happens to their experience of belonging. They may still attend the church, work within the organisation, participate in meetings and fulfil their responsibilities, but internally, their place within that community is becoming increasingly uncertain.
They are present, but they are no longer experiencing genuine belonging.
And sometimes, the very people entrusted with protecting their dignity are the ones undermining it.
Dignity Is About Much More Than Sexual Misconduct
When we speak about women having their dignity violated, the conversation often moves immediately towards sexual harassment, sexual misconduct or inappropriate behaviour.
Those are important issues, but human dignity encompasses far more.
A woman's dignity can be undermined when her responsibilities are dismissed, her professional contribution is disregarded, her legitimate concerns are ignored, or she is repeatedly treated as though her presence and perspective are inconvenient.
It can happen through missed meetings, withheld communication, public humiliation, exclusion from decisions relevant to her responsibilities, or patterns of behaviour that continually communicate that she is less important than those around her.
These experiences may appear small when considered individually. But when they become a pattern, their cumulative effect can be devastating.
I know this because I have experienced it.
I am a woman with a strong sense of self and a well-developed sense of internal authority. I do not need someone else's position or approval to establish my worth. Yet I have experienced leadership environments in which I felt that my strength, independence and natural authority were met with attempts to diminish me.
I believe that some leaders respond to strong women by attempting to establish superiority through disrespect, humiliation or exclusion.
I want to be very clear that this is not a criticism of all men. I have known male leaders who value strong women, respect their capabilities and welcome their contribution. They do not need women to become smaller in order to feel secure in their own leadership.
But I have also encountered leadership behaviour that left me feeling profoundly dishonoured.
And I want to give that experience a name.
It was an assault on my lived experience of dignity.
The Hidden Connection Between Dignity and Belonging
One of the most painful discoveries I made was that when my dignity was being undermined, my belonging was being undermined alongside it.
Think about what it means to belong.
Belonging is not simply having your name on a membership register, holding an employment contract, attending a church or being included in a group photograph.
Belonging means being recognised as a person whose presence has value.
It means having room to contribute, to disagree respectfully, to ask questions, to exercise appropriate authority and to exist without having to diminish yourself to remain acceptable.
When someone is repeatedly humiliated or dishonoured, they begin to question whether there is room for them in that community.
They may start monitoring their words, suppressing their concerns, avoiding particular people or surrendering legitimate responsibilities simply to maintain peace.
Eventually, remaining in the community may require them to become someone they are not.
That is not healthy belonging. That is conditional acceptance.
And when acceptance depends upon a person surrendering their dignity, the community has developed a serious problem.
When Leadership Confuses Authority With Superiority
I have encountered leaders who appear to understand authority as the right to make other people subordinate to them.
There is an important distinction here.
Organisations require leadership structures, defined responsibilities, accountability and legitimate decision-making authority. A person may report to a manager or serve under a particular governance structure without their human dignity being compromised.
But organisational authority does not establish human superiority.
A leader's position does not make another person less worthy of respect.
It does not give them permission to humiliate, disregard, diminish or psychologically overpower the people entrusted to their care.
Within Christian leadership, this distinction should be particularly clear.
Jesus consistently challenged the use of power for self-exaltation. In Mark 10:42–45, he contrasted rulers who exercise authority over others with the servant-hearted leadership expected among his followers.
Christian leadership is not permission to dominate. It is a responsibility to serve.
And service cannot be reconciled with deliberately stripping another human being of their sense of worth.
I believe this matters profoundly to God.
I often think of it through the image of a parent entrusting beloved children to the care of others. Those entrusted with their care are expected to protect, nurture and honour them. Imagine discovering that instead, those caregivers had humiliated them, made them feel worthless and taught them that their safety depended upon unquestioning submission.
How would a loving parent respond?
That image expresses something of how I understand God's concern for the dignity of his people.
Those entrusted with spiritual leadership are custodians of a responsibility. They are not owners of the people they lead.
The Particular Wound Experienced by Strong Women
I want to speak directly to women who recognise this pattern.
Perhaps you have spent years in a church or organisation where you have been expected to serve faithfully but have not been permitted to exercise your gifts, voice or judgement without resistance.
Perhaps your competence has been welcomed when it benefits the organisation but treated as threatening when you begin asking difficult questions.
Perhaps you have been called difficult, intimidating, rebellious or unsubmissive because you refused to surrender your own judgement.
Or perhaps no one has used those words at all. Instead, you have experienced a gradual withdrawal of respect, communication, recognition or inclusion.
You may have spent years trying to understand what you were doing wrong.
I want you to consider another possibility.
The problem may not be that you have failed to belong. The problem may be that the environment has made your belonging conditional upon becoming smaller.
That is a very different understanding of what has happened.
It changes the questions you ask.
Instead of asking, "How do I become acceptable to these people?" you begin asking, "What is happening in this environment, and why am I being required to surrender something essential about myself in order to remain?"
That is where informed choice begins.
Why the Wound Can Be So Deep
When I experienced these things, the pain was extraordinary.
I have always had a strong sense of myself, yet the cumulative effect of being dishonoured and devalued was deeply distressing.
I remember feeling that I wanted to curl up and disappear.
It was not simply disappointment about a role or frustration with leadership decisions. It was something much deeper.
My experience of being respected as a human being had been profoundly shaken.
When these experiences occur within a community to which someone has devoted ten, twenty or thirty years, the consequences can extend far beyond the immediate mistreatment.
Their relationships, identity, spiritual life, service, memories and sense of home may all be connected to that community.
They may have raised children there, invested years of voluntary service, developed friendships and believed deeply in the organisation's purpose.
When their dignity is repeatedly undermined, they may eventually face the devastating possibility that the place they considered home is no longer a place where they can safely be themselves.
This is why dignity wounds cannot always be understood as isolated interpersonal disagreements.
Sometimes they are wounds of belonging. And sometimes they are wounds created or sustained by the structures and cultures of the institutions themselves.
Restoring Dignity: The Healing Journey
There is something I want every person who has experienced this kind of treatment to understand.
Your dignity was never dependent upon the people who failed to honour it.
They may have damaged your confidence, undermined your sense of belonging, humiliated you or caused you to question your value.
But they did not create your worth, and they do not have the authority to determine it.
Your dignity is inherent.
Healing, therefore, is not about becoming worthy again.
It is about restoring your relationship with the worth that was always yours.
1. Naming What Happened
The first movement towards healing is often finding language for the experience.
Many people know they have been hurt but cannot explain why the hurt is so profound.
They may describe feeling dismissed, invisible, humiliated, unwanted or powerless.
Naming the experience as a violation of dignity can bring clarity.
It allows a person to recognise that their distress may be connected to how they were treated, rather than evidence that something is fundamentally wrong with them.
This is particularly important when harmful behaviour has been normalised within a community.
What has become familiar is not necessarily healthy.
2. Separating Your Worth From Their Treatment
One of the most important tasks in healing is learning to distinguish between what happened to you and what it says about you.
Being disregarded does not make you insignificant.
Being excluded does not make you unworthy of belonging.
Being humiliated does not make you inferior.
Being denied appropriate authority does not mean you lack competence.
The treatment you received is information about an interaction, a relationship or an environment. It is not an objective measurement of your human value.
This distinction helps restore the internal separation between your identity and the behaviour of others.
3. Understanding the Patterns
Healing also requires understanding how the harm occurred.
Was communication repeatedly withheld? Were responsibilities assigned without corresponding authority? Were legitimate questions interpreted as disloyalty? Was disagreement treated as rebellion? Was respect offered only when you complied?
Recognising these patterns matters because it allows people to move beyond endless attempts to interpret individual incidents.
They begin to see the structure of the experience.
And once a pattern becomes visible, it becomes possible to make informed decisions about it.
This is a central part of the work of Spirit Led Institute: helping people understand human behaviour and the systems in which it operates, so that harm can be recognised, prevented, addressed and healed.
4. Recovering Internal Authority
Repeated experiences of humiliation can teach a person to look outside themselves for permission to think, speak, decide or act.
They may begin second-guessing their judgement, suppressing their observations or waiting for approval before exercising abilities they once used confidently.
Restoration involves recovering the capacity to trust their own discernment.
It means recognising that respectful disagreement is not disobedience, that having boundaries is not rebellion, and that exercising judgement does not automatically constitute a threat to legitimate authority.
Internal authority is not the belief that we are always right.
It is the recognition that we are entitled to think, evaluate, question, learn and make responsible choices without surrendering our personhood to someone else.
5. Grieving the Loss of Belonging
Sometimes healing requires acknowledging that a community we loved was not what we believed it to be.
This can be a profound grief.
We may grieve the relationships, the shared purpose, the years invested, the opportunities lost and the future we imagined.
We may also grieve the version of ourselves who believed that faithfulness, hard work and goodwill would eventually be met with respect.
This grief deserves attention.
It is possible to recognise harmful behaviour without denying that there were also meaningful relationships, beautiful experiences and genuine contributions.
Healing does not require rewriting an entire history as worthless.
It requires making room for the whole truth.
6. Rebuilding Belonging Without Surrendering Yourself
Restoration does not necessarily mean returning to the community where the harm occurred.
Nor does it require immediately finding another community to replace it.
Sometimes belonging must first be restored within ourselves.
We learn to inhabit our own lives without continually seeking permission to exist as we are.
We begin to recognise environments where our contribution is welcomed, our boundaries are respected and our individuality is not treated as a problem to be corrected.
We discover that genuine belonging does not require the abandonment of dignity.
And we become increasingly capable of recognising the difference between a community that welcomes our authentic participation and one that merely rewards our compliance.
A Word to Christian Leaders
I also want to address those entrusted with leadership.
If you feel threatened by the strength, intelligence, competence or independence of the people you lead, that is something you need to examine.
If you respond to challenge by withholding respect, excluding people, humiliating them or reducing their legitimate authority, you need to consider the consequences of your behaviour.
Leadership is not validated by the submission of diminished people.
It is demonstrated through the responsible exercise of authority, the protection of human dignity and the creation of environments where people can contribute without fear of humiliation.
Christian institutions should be places where human worth is recognised, not places where it must be defended against those in authority.
The people entrusted to your care are not your possessions.
Their dignity does not belong to you.
Why Spirit Led Institute Exists
Spirit Led Institute emerged from my own journey of trying to understand what had happened, why it happened, how the patterns operated and what genuine healing required.
What began as a deeply personal search became a much broader body of work examining human behaviour, institutional structures, leadership, safeguarding, dignity, belonging and restoration.
I do not want people to remain trapped in environments they do not understand.
I want them to recognise the patterns operating around them.
I want them to understand the difference between legitimate authority and harmful control, between healthy accountability and humiliation, between genuine belonging and conditional acceptance.
Most importantly, I want them to recover the capacity to make informed choices.
Some people may choose to remain within their communities and work towards change. Others may recognise that leaving is necessary. Both decisions deserve to be made with clarity, agency and an understanding of what is happening.
And for those who have already left, there is still the work of restoration.
The restoration of confidence.
The restoration of internal authority.
The restoration of the capacity to belong without self-abandonment.
The restoration of a lived sense of dignity.
You do not have to earn back the dignity that was always yours.
You do not have to become smaller to make someone else feel powerful.
And you do not have to accept humiliation as the price of belonging.
Human dignity matters.
It matters in our churches, our workplaces, our institutions, our families and every environment where human beings exercise authority over one another.
It matters because people matter.
And until our systems, cultures and leadership practices reflect that truth, there is work to be done.
That is the work to which I have committed Spirit Led Institute.
Sharon Mackenzie Founder, Spirit Led Institute

