Skip to main content

Dignity & relational communication · 12 min read

Silent Grace or Silent Treatment?

When Boundaries Become Control

Sharon Mackenzie SpiritRSPrac · Founder & Educator

  • Diploma of Counselling
  • Accredited Chaplain
  • Narrative Practice Practitioner · Health & Harmony Colleges
  • Advanced Aromatherapy Practitioner · Health & Harmony Colleges
  • Trauma-Informed Care

Counselling and chaplaincy training and trauma-informed care inform Sharon’s educational work.

There is something happening across social media that has been concerning me for quite some time. I've been watching it unfold on Facebook, YouTube and through videos circulating from TikTok. There is a growing culture of tarot card readers, intuitive readers, psychics, clairvoyants and other social media personalities offering relationship advice to increasingly large audiences.

Now, I am not talking about somebody simply picking up a pack of tarot cards and giving a reading. What concerns me is what happens when those readings move beyond interpretation and become something resembling relationship counselling. Some of these readings go on for hours. The people presenting them develop substantial followings, and their audiences begin receiving advice about how to manage relationships, respond to conflict and deal with people from their past.

Much of this advice is being offered by people who may have no formal training in counselling, psychology or relational practice. And while some of it may sound wonderfully empowering, I think we need to examine what is actually being encouraged.

One particular message has caught my attention.

Stay silent until somebody approaches you properly.

Sometimes it is called silent grace. Sometimes it is described as standing in your power. There is talk about old energy returning, karmic relationships, twin flames and people from the past coming back into your life. And woven through these discussions is the suggestion that if somebody approaches you in a way you don't like, you should simply refuse to respond until they get it right.

Now, that might sound empowering.

But I want to ask a very important question.

When does maintaining a boundary become an attempt to control another human being?

The Problem With Silent Grace

I was listening to one of these readings recently while working at my desk. The reader was discussing what she called old energy returning, which was essentially a way of describing somebody from the past attempting to reconnect.

Her advice was that if this person approached in the wrong energy, or failed to communicate in the expected way, the listener should remain silent. Don't respond. Wait until they approach you properly.

And I sat there thinking about what that actually means.

If somebody is approaching you in a harmful, threatening or abusive way, then of course you have every right to protect yourself. You do not have to engage with somebody who is harming you. Your safety matters, and there are circumstances where no communication is the most appropriate response.

But that is not the situation I am talking about.

I am talking about ordinary human relationships. Relationships where there has been a disagreement, a misunderstanding, a falling out or perhaps a long period without communication. Maybe somebody has been reflecting on what happened. Maybe they have finally gathered the courage to reach out. Maybe they want to apologise, or perhaps they simply want to begin a conversation.

And they approach you.

But they don't approach you in quite the way you expected.

So you remain silent.

Not because you are unsafe, but because you have decided they must communicate in a particular way before you will acknowledge them.

And somehow, this is being presented as grace.

I would question that.

Have You Actually Told Them What You Expect?

Here is something I think we need to consider.

Perhaps somebody hurt you in the past. Perhaps you believe they owe you an apology, and perhaps they do.

But have you ever told them that?

Have you actually sat down and communicated what happened, how you experienced it and what you need from them?

Or have you decided privately that you will not respond until they approach you with the apology you believe you deserve?

Imagine that person finally reaching out with a simple, "Hey, how are you going?"

And your response is silence because you are waiting for something entirely different.

How are they supposed to know?

How can somebody be held responsible for failing to meet an expectation that has never been communicated to them?

We sometimes expect people to understand what we need without ever giving them the opportunity to hear it.

And then we interpret their failure to meet that expectation as a reason to withhold communication.

I think we need to be very careful about that.

When Silence Becomes Manipulation

There is a difference between choosing not to communicate because you need time, space or safety, and deliberately withholding communication to make somebody behave in a particular way.

If the intention behind your silence is to create a vacuum so that the other person keeps approaching, keeps trying and eventually says exactly what you want them to say, then I would argue that you have moved beyond maintaining a boundary.

You are attempting to influence their behaviour through silence.

And that can be manipulative.

It can also be terribly cruel.

Consider somebody who has been reflecting on a difficult relationship. Perhaps they have made mistakes. Perhaps they have been hurt themselves. Perhaps they have spent weeks or months wondering whether to reach out.

Eventually, they find the courage to send a message.

And they receive nothing.

No acknowledgement. No indication that the message has been received. No simple explanation that the other person is not ready to communicate.

Just silence.

If you have ever reached out to somebody you love or care about and been met with that kind of silence, you may understand how painful it can be.

Now imagine being told that the person ignoring you is demonstrating grace.

I struggle with that.

Because to me, grace should not require us to diminish the dignity of another human being.

You Can Maintain Your Boundaries Without Removing Somebody Else's Dignity

Much of my work through Spirit Led Institute, my counselling practice and the books I have written centres on human dignity.

And human dignity does not belong exclusively to the person who has been hurt.

It also belongs to the person attempting to communicate.

It belongs to the person who has made a mistake.

It belongs to the person who is trying, perhaps rather clumsily, to repair something that has been damaged.

You do not have to abandon your boundaries to recognise that dignity.

You do not have to forgive somebody before you are ready. You do not have to agree to a conversation you are not prepared to have. And you certainly do not have to expose yourself to further harm.

But where communication is safe and appropriate, you can acknowledge another human being without surrendering your own authority.

You can say something as simple as:

Thank you for reaching out. I'm not ready to talk to you just yet. If that changes in the future, I'll get back to you. Have a nice day.

That's it.

You have maintained your boundary.

You have maintained your dignity.

You have retained your right to decide whether or when further communication takes place.

And you have acknowledged the dignity of the person who approached you.

Nobody has been humiliated. Nobody has been required to submit. Nobody has been left trying to guess what they must do to receive a response.

You have communicated clearly, respectfully and with integrity.

And isn't that a much better expression of grace?

Standing in Your Power Does Not Require Somebody Else to Lose Theirs

There is a great deal of language circulating on social media about standing in your power, protecting your energy and refusing to entertain people who approach you in what is described as the wrong energy.

Some of that language can sound incredibly reassuring, particularly to somebody who has experienced relational hurt.

But I think we need to examine what empowerment actually looks like in our relationships.

If maintaining your power requires another person to keep approaching you until they finally satisfy an expectation you have never communicated, what kind of power are we talking about?

If somebody must say exactly the right words before you will acknowledge their existence, is that really grace?

Or have we simply given a more attractive name to the silent treatment?

You can be a strong, confident person with healthy boundaries and still treat other people with respect.

In fact, I would argue that there is considerable strength in being able to communicate clearly without surrendering your position.

You can say no.

You can ask for time.

You can explain that you are not ready.

You can communicate what you need.

And you can do all of those things without attempting to control how another person behaves.

That is not weakness.

That is integrity.

What Are We Teaching Young People About Relationships?

One of my greatest concerns is the influence this advice may be having on younger people.

We have an entire generation accessing relationship guidance through social media. They are listening to people who may be very engaging, very confident and very convincing, but who may not have the training or experience to understand the consequences of the advice they are giving.

And when that advice repeatedly encourages people to withdraw, remain silent, ignore communication and wait for others to approach them in precisely the right way, I think we need to ask what kind of relational culture we are creating.

Are we teaching people how to communicate?

Are we teaching them how to repair relationships?

Are we teaching them how to maintain boundaries while recognising the dignity of others?

Or are we teaching them that silence is a form of power and that withholding communication is an acceptable way to make another person comply with our expectations?

That concerns me.

Because relationships are not always tidy.

People do not always approach us perfectly. They do not always have the right words. Sometimes they are nervous. Sometimes they are ashamed. Sometimes they do not fully understand what has happened or how the other person has experienced it.

And sometimes they are simply trying to open a door.

Surely we can make room for imperfect human communication without abandoning our own dignity.

Grace Is Not the Same as Silence

I want to return to this expression, silent grace.

Because I think we need to be careful about what we are calling grace.

If somebody has hurt you and they are attempting to communicate, perhaps they deserve the opportunity to be heard. Perhaps they want to apologise. Perhaps they want to explain something. Perhaps they have been reflecting on what happened and want to make things right.

That does not mean you are obligated to reconcile with them.

It does not mean you have to accept an apology.

And it does not mean that every attempt at communication deserves an ongoing conversation.

But when it is safe and appropriate to do so, there is something deeply dignifying about acknowledging another human being and communicating your own position clearly.

You can maintain your internal authority without stripping somebody else of theirs.

You can exercise your right to choose without using that choice to manipulate.

You can protect your boundaries without demanding that another person submit to an unspoken set of expectations.

And you can offer grace without surrendering yourself.

To me, that is far more powerful than silence used to force somebody to get it right.

A Final Thought

This is not about shaming people who have followed this advice, and it is not about attacking people who offer intuitive or tarot readings.

It is about encouraging us to think carefully about the relational advice we receive, particularly when that advice is presented as empowerment.

Before deciding to ignore somebody because they have not approached you properly, perhaps ask yourself a few questions.

Have I actually communicated what I need?

Am I choosing silence because I need safety or space, or because I want this person to behave differently?

Is there a way I can maintain my boundaries while still acknowledging their dignity?

And am I treating this person in a way that reflects the values I want to live by?

We do not have to get every interaction right. We do not have to respond perfectly. And we certainly do not have to make ourselves available to everybody who wants our attention.

But I do believe we can become more thoughtful about how we treat one another.

Human dignity is not something we extend only when somebody approaches us correctly.

It is something we recognise because they are human.

And when we can maintain our own boundaries while respecting the dignity of another person, I believe we place ourselves in a position of genuine integrity.

Perhaps that is where true grace stands.

Back to From Sharon
Waterfall cascading beside sandstone cliffs above a eucalyptus valleyA koala resting in a eucalyptus tree in golden light